COUNCIL chiefs should throw out a Waitrose plan for Knowle according to the majority of people who left comments online for decisions makers.Of the 21 comments posted on Solihull Metropolitan Borough Council’s website, 16 are against the St John’s Close scheme and five are for it.
Click the headline or link below to read the rest of this story.
Kimberley Developments wants to knock down the village hall for the store and replace it on the site of the former bowling green by the Red Lion car park.
Ten bungalows that run parallel with the High Street would be demolished to make way for parking and be replaced in three sites in the area.
Roger Hancox wrote: “The road system around the village is clearly not suited to providing access to this major development.
“There does not seem to be any pressing needs for a new supermarket, the village already has a Tesco and range of local shops.”
Victoria Hall wrote: “Knowle and Dorridge residents pay above average prices for property and do so to some extent in order to live in a village enviroment. I object to this proposal wholeheartedly.”
Mrs I M Baker opposed the bid to move six of the bungalows to near to the village hall.
She said: “They will suffer continual disturbance from the restaurants and businesses to the rear and disturbance and lack of privacy from the car park at the front.
“Access to these bungalows for visitors, carers and emergency vehicles also looks problematic.”
Joanne Guy said: “The proposed development is simply the retail equivelent of garden grabbing.
“The proposal will cause relatively open sites in the historic core of the village to be 'infilled' with a huge builidng out of all proportion to the character of the local area.”
What do you think? Leave your comments below. No registration required. Mr & Mrs Bignell wrote: “We feel that Knowle is allready well served with shops and any new supermarket will probably result in the loss of our small independent shops.”
Paul Gilbert says the 52 extra car parking spaces, to make 180, will have to take on spaces lost from the Red Lion and on-street parking.
He accused developer of ‘massaging of the traffic impact is by using very dubious assumptions’.
Tony & Chris Reed wrote: “A new Waitrose at over twice the sguare footage of the current Tesco is overkill and will reduce the trade in the independents who have served us so well over many years.”
Heather Lewis wrote: “The village already has a village hall and retirement dwellings so it is difficult to see what the village will gain by demolishing these to replace them with a store which is too large for the plot for which it is intended and will add to considerable parking problems in the area.”
But D.W.Freeman said: “Knowle, unfortunatly, ceased to be a village in the 1970's and is now a thriving business community. Its shopping should reflect this.”
Steve Taylor wrote: “I support the application by Waitrose, which I think will be good for Knowle. It will also provide a new village hall to replace the existing damp, musty hall.”
And John Lynch said the area is ‘unsightly’ and ‘none of the current car parks are interconnected so there is a lot of traffic just going between car parks’.
He said the current road system is ‘unsuitable’ with much on-street parking and a larger supermarket would bring in out of town shopping.
Charles Jukes wrote: “The ‘Waitrose’ project offers a once only opportunity to develop the village facilities and gain a premier supermarket grocer.
“For too long the village has had only I real food supplier in Tesco and a High Street dominated by Indian restaurants, estate agents, ladies hairdressers and banks.
“The arrival of Waitrose will certainly attract more visitors to the village but this in turn offers a great opportunity for the development of a more diverse range of shops for the benefit of all.”
He warned Knowle ‘will eventually die’ without change but said the plans are not suitable because of concerns about lorry access into St Johns Close from the High Street.
Rob Ericsson said the village green is ‘muddy and ill kept’ and the bungalows are ‘ugly and cheap’ with parking ‘confusing and difficult’.
He said: “Tesco is a desperate shopping experience. No wonder most people have to shop outside our village with the real impact on our carbon footprint.
“As people have to shop outside this area, the other shops in our village lose custom. The green grocers and butchers and other shops would be assisted by an increased population choosing to shop within their local environment.”
Most people who attended a public meeting at Arden School last week opposed the plan. Click here for the report from The Silhillian and here for all Waitrose stories.
The Knowle Society, which organised the event, yesterday published a full and abridged report on the meeting. It is seeking responses, click here for the response form.
Click here for the full list of comments from the main application and here, here and here for comments on the other applications for the bungalows.