Sunday, 24 March 2013

Approve larger Four Ashes homes plan, council report says

A LARGER plan for homes on a Bentley Heath field should be approved, a council planning officer has said.

Click the headline or link below to read the rest of this story.

Crest Nicholson’s plans for 44 homes off Four Ashes Road overcomes objections over a previous plan for 38 houses, the Solihull Metropolitan Borough Council officer said.

The council opposed that plan and it was thrown out on appeal as it was judged to not provide enough homes to meet council policies and provided too many four-bedroom houses.

But the officers’ latest report says these two issues have now been addressed and the new scheme should be approved (see map here).

And it revealed the developer is has launched a legal challenge against The Planning Inspectorates’ appeal decision on the 38 homes plan.

Councillors on the planning committee will be asked to make a decision on Wednesday April 3.

The site and neighbouring fields is earmarked for 150 homes in council policies on where estates should go in the coming two decades.

The council report says of the latest scheme: “The residential development of the site is acceptable in principle.

“This is in line with a previous appeal decision, albeit dismissed.”

It says: “The application provides for an appropriate level and mix of affordable housing which overcomes the previous concerns at appeal regarding density and mix, which now provides two, three and four bedroom houses.”

The inspectorate threw out the 38-homes plan as it had 29.7 dwellings per hectare (dph) compared to a council policy which demands 30 to 50dph. The new plan would have 34 dph.

It also rejected the plan as it only had four-bedroom homes in the 23 that would be offered on the open market. The rest would be affordable.

Under the new plan, there would be four, two-bedroom; seven, three-bedroom and 16, four-bedroom open market homes.

Some four residents’ letters opposed the scheme with concerns over access onto “very busy” Four Ashes Road, extra congestion and “piecemeal” development of the entire site.

Yet the report says Crest Nicholson allege the Planning Inspectorate “misinterpreted and misapplied” council policy over the dph for the 38 homes plan.

It said the dph is “out-dated” and did not correctly apply the Government’s National Planning Policy Framework, which puts more onus on giving default approval to development.

And it said its 29.7dph means the plan falls within the 30 to 50dph range.

The mix of house sizes should be considered for all 150 homes and across the borough, not just its 38, the developer has said.

The inspector was “factually incorrect” to state the site is within the Green Belt, it added.

A two-storey building with 51 “extra care apartments” for OAPs has been submitted for the adjacent field. No decision has been made by the council.


What do you think? Leave your comments below. No registration required. Posts must abide by the terms and conditions. Report comments at news@thesilhillian.co.uk.

Click here to get stories by email.